On this page
In 2019 a team led by psychologist David Yeager published a large, nationally representative test of a growth mindset lesson in US public schools. The paper, Yeager et al. (2019), "A national experiment reveals where a growth mindset improves achievement", in *Nature*, asked whether a short online lesson saying abilities can be developed could change teenagers' grades across a whole country. The answer: yes, a little, for some students, in some schools.
What did the National Study of Learning Mindsets test?
The study drew a stratified random sample of 65 regular US public schools that included 12,490 ninth-grade students, each randomly assigned to a condition, according to the open-access full text. Ninth grade in the US is roughly Class 9 in India: ages 14-15 and the first year of high school.
The intervention was two self-administered online sessions of about 25 minutes each, held roughly 20 days apart during school hours (methods). Students learned that the brain grows stronger through hard learning and wrote advice for a future struggling student. The control group did a similar online module about brain functions that did not mention beliefs about intelligence.
Three choices make it stronger than most: an independent company collected the data, the analysis plan was pre-registered, and teachers did not know who got which module (paper).
How much did growth mindset improve grades?
The pre-registered target group was the 6,320 students whose grades were at or below their own school's median. For them, end-of-year grades in core subjects rose by 0.10 grade points on a 4-point scale, a standardised effect size of 0.11 (Yeager et al., 2019).
The paper's model estimates that the share of these students finishing ninth grade with a D or F average (GPA below 2.0) fell from 46% to 41% (Yeager et al., 2019).
For students above their school's median, the effect on grades was 0.01 grade points and not statistically significant (Extended Data Table 1).
In an exploratory analysis of the 6,690 students in the 41 schools that supplied course data, 36% of treated students took advanced maths (algebra II or higher) the next year, against 33% of controls (paper). The authors flag that this analysis was not pre-registered.
Where did it work, and where did it not?
The effect was not the same everywhere. Lower-achieving students in the highest-achieving schools gained less on grades. The largest gains came in schools where classmates in the control group already chose harder maths problems on a challenge-seeking task, which the authors read as peer norms that support taking on challenges (Yeager et al., 2019). The authors note they cannot draw causal conclusions about school norms, because the norms were measured, not manipulated.
Their image is a seed and soil: the idea grows only where the people around a student treat hard problems as normal.
Does the growth mindset effect replicate?
Partly, and the debate is live. A follow-up experiment in Norway with 6,541 students, by several of the same authors, repeated the rise in students choosing advanced maths (Rege et al., 2021, *American Psychologist*).
Critics read the wider evidence as weaker. A 2018 meta-analysis of 43 intervention studies found weak overall effects on achievement, with some signs of benefit for low-income or academically at-risk students (Sisk et al., 2018, *Psychological Science*). A 2023 review of 63 studies found an average effect of d = 0.05, which was not significant after correcting for publication bias, and d = 0.02 in the 6 highest-quality studies (Macnamara and Burgoyne, 2023, *Psychological Bulletin*).
None of this was tested on Indian students, board exams or JEE and NEET preparation. For the wider picture, see our summary of what the big growth mindset studies found, and Carol Dweck's research on praise for where the idea started.
What can a Class 9-12 or JEE-NEET student take from it?
What follows is our inference from the study, not something it tested. A belief alone moved grades only slightly. What seemed to matter was belief plus an environment where hard work is normal. So build the soil, not just the slogan.
Name the struggle correctly. When a rotational mechanics problem beats you, write "I have not learned this method yet", then find which step broke.
Choose one harder problem a day. Pick the question you would normally skip, attempt it fully, then study the solution line by line.
Pick your peer group on purpose. Study with friends who talk openly about what they got wrong, not only about marks.
Ask for help early. The lesson framed asking for help as part of learning, not proof of low ability.
Track process, not only scores. After each mock test, note one method you now understand that you did not last week.
If the sticking point is usually a wrong method, the Fermi Problem Library has worked problems with a step-by-step solver that explains the reasoning rather than printing an answer. Struggle that leads somewhere is the idea behind productive failure.
If exam pressure starts to feel like more than everyday stress, talk to someone you trust or call Tele MANAS on 14416.



