On this page
You topped your school in Class 10, or you are in your drop year and your mock scores are finally climbing. And a quiet voice says: this isn’t really you. You got lucky. Someone will notice. That voice has a name, and knowing what research says about it makes it easier to answer.
What is imposter syndrome in students?
Imposter syndrome is the feeling that your success is due to luck, a lucky break or extra effort rather than ability, together with a fear of being found out. Psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes named it the “imposter phenomenon” in a 1978 paper on high-achieving women (Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice).
On her own site, Pauline Clance writes that people with these feelings believe their success came from “some mysterious fluke or luck or great effort”, and that “unless they go to gargantuan efforts to do so, success can not be repeated.” The fear underneath, in her words: “next time, I will blow it.”
It describes a way of thinking, not your ability. Feeling like a fraud is not evidence that you are one.
How common are imposter feelings, and who has them?
More common than most students guess. A 2020 systematic review in the Journal of General Internal Medicine pooled 62 studies with 14,161 participants (Bravata and colleagues). Reported rates ranged from 9% to 82%, largely depending on which questionnaire and cut-off a study used. The same review found imposter feelings in both men and women, and in age groups from adolescents to late-career professionals.
Two more findings from that review matter for families. Imposter feelings often occurred alongside depression and anxiety. And in the research up to 2018 that the authors searched, no published study had tested a treatment for them, so be wary of anyone promising a quick cure.
Why do toppers and droppers feel like frauds?
For a topper, the label becomes the problem. If you believe your rank came from luck or from unusually hard work, every new test is a chance to be exposed. For many, Class 11 is where this first shows up: the syllabus jumps, the batch is full of other toppers, and an ordinary test score feels like proof. If that is you, our four-week reset for Class 10 toppers struggling in Class 11 deals with the study side.
For a repeater, the thought often runs the other way. We did not find a study of drop-year students specifically, so read this as a description, not a research finding. Last year’s result starts to feel like the “real” you, and this year’s better mocks get explained away as easy papers or lucky guesses. When the year goes flat, that story gets louder; our three-part reset for a drop year that feels flat helps with the routine.
Both groups make the move Clance describes: success gets credited to anything except your own ability.
How do you answer an imposter thought?
Instead of arguing with the thought, check it against the evidence. Try this three-column check on paper when the thought shows up.
Write the thought exactly. “I only cleared the cut-off because the paper was easy.”
List the evidence, both ways. For: the paper felt easier than the last one. Against: everyone sat the same paper, so the comparison was fair; you solved rotational motion questions you could not do in June.
Write one next action. “Tomorrow, redo two of those rotation questions without notes, to check the method is mine.”
For a topper, “Everyone here is smarter than me” becomes, after the evidence column, “Others solved the hard question; I set it up correctly and lost it on a sign error.” The next action is practising sign conventions: a skill, not a verdict.
The redo step is where a tool can help. The Fermi Problem Library has a step-by-step solver that explains the reasoning, so you can compare your method with each step instead of only the final answer. If the doubt is about a whole topic, the Fermi Concept Library covers every concept in physics, chemistry, biology, mathematics and computing, so you can see whether the gap is real and how big it is.
What can parents say to a child who feels like a fraud?
Praise the work you saw, not the label. “You’re a natural” can leave a child afraid of being caught being ordinary. Our post on Carol Dweck’s growth mindset research and what it means for praise explains why the kind of praise matters.
A few lines to try with toppers and repeaters alike:
“I saw you redo those problems on your own. That’s how it stays yours.”
“One bad test tells us about a chapter, not about you.”
“Do you want help with the plan, or do you want me to just listen?”
If imposter thoughts come with weeks of low mood, poor sleep, panic or not wanting to study at all, talk to a school counsellor or a doctor. Tele MANAS, the Health Ministry’s free 24x7 mental-health helpline, answers on 14416 or 1800-891-4416 (details from IIT Kanpur’s counselling service).
