On this page
Your child's maths marks went from 18 to 26 out of 40, but their class rank stayed where it was. It is easy to notice only the rank. Here is how to spot real improvement, what research says about the kind of praise that helps, and what to say at the dinner table.
Why does class rank hide real progress?
Rank tells you where your child stands against the rest of the class, not whether they learned more than last month. If the whole class does better, a child who improved a lot can keep the same rank. A bad day for classmates can push a rank up for no reason at all. Our post on why toppers often score lower the next time shows how much luck moves a single test score.
Constant comparison can also cost children something. In a study of 103,558 15-year-olds in 26 countries, Herbert Marsh and Kit-Tai Hau found that the higher a school's average achievement, the lower its students' academic self-concept, and this held in all 26 countries. This is the big-fish-little-pond effect: a student tends to rate their own ability lower when surrounded by stronger peers.
CBSE has moved this way too. In July 2022, CBSE decided not to declare merit lists to eliminate "unhealthy competition", and said it would not assign first, second and third divisions.
What kind of praise actually helps?
Praise the work, not the child's brain. In six studies by Claudia Mueller and Carol Dweck, fifth graders praised for intelligence showed less persistence, less enjoyment and worse performance after a failure than children praised for effort. Children praised for intelligence were also more likely to describe it as a fixed trait.
How you give feedback matters as much as whether you give it. In Ruth Butler's 1988 study of 132 pupils, interest and performance were highest after individual comments, while grades generally undermined both. John Hattie and Helen Timperley's review of feedback research reached a similar conclusion: feedback is one of the most powerful influences on learning, but its effect can be positive or negative depending on its type and how it is given.
How do you notice improvement worth celebrating?
Use a simple "then, now, how" check after every test. Compare like with like: the same subject, a similar kind of test.
Then: What did they score last time in this subject, and which questions did they lose marks on?
Now: What changed, beyond the total?
How: What did they do differently to get there?
Improvement often shows up before the total moves much. Look for:
A higher score in their weakest subject, even if the strong ones dipped slightly
Fewer marks lost to calculation slips or missed units
Questions attempted that they used to skip
Finishing the paper on time
A topic that went wrong last time now done correctly
Asking the teacher a question without being pushed
A worked example. Say Aarav, in Class 9, scored 18 out of 40 in maths in his first unit test and 26 in the second. His rank did not change, because the class average also rose. The useful facts are that he gained 8 marks, and that most of them came from linear equations, the chapter he had redone at the weekend. That is the thing to celebrate.
If the weak subject has gaps from earlier years, the Fermi Concept Library has a lesson on each concept in physics, chemistry, biology and mathematics, so your child can go back to the exact idea they missed.
What should you say when the marks go up?
Keep it short, specific and about their work. A four-line script:
Name the change: "Maths went from 18 to 26. That's 8 marks in one month."
Ask how: "What did you do differently this time?"
Connect it to the method: "So redoing the equations chapter worked."
Agree the next small step: "Which chapter do you want to try that on next?"
What to avoid:
"What did Riya get?" This turns their gain into a comparison again.
"You're so smart." It praises a trait instead of the work, the kind of praise that Mueller and Dweck's studies linked to less persistence after failure.
"Why not 35?" Save the next target for the next step, not the moment of celebration.
A celebration can be small: their choice of dinner, a note on the fridge, or a page in a notebook where they record each gain and how they earned it. Our guide on stopping siblings fighting over who scored better has more on keeping marks out of family comparisons.
If your child seems low for weeks, not just after one test, talk to their school counsellor or call Tele MANAS on 14416, a free, round-the-clock national mental health helpline (Tele MANAS listing).
When the next coaching report arrives, read it for change over time first; see how to read your child's coaching test report and rank.
