On this page
The paper comes home with a number nobody expected, and you both feel the jolt. A unit test is small; the talk you have tonight lasts longer than the mark. Here is a plan for that talk, a way to read the paper together, and one change to try next.
What should you say first when your child scores low in a unit test?
How you react to failure may reach your child more than what you believe about intelligence. In a 2016 Psychological Science paper, Kyla Haimovitz and Carol Dweck found that children could accurately tell whether their parents saw failure as debilitating or enhancing, but not what their parents believed about intelligence. Parents who saw failure as debilitating focused on performance and ability instead of learning, and their children tended to believe intelligence is fixed.
How you phrase things matters too. In Kamins and Dweck's 1999 study, 67 children aged 5 and 6 role-played tasks with a setback. They showed more helpless responses, including blaming themselves, after criticism aimed at them as people than after criticism of how they had worked.
So keep the first conversation short, and keep it about the paper, not about the child. A script you can adapt:
"Thanks for showing me. I can see you're disappointed."
"One test tells us what to fix. It doesn't say what you're capable of."
"Shall we look through it together tomorrow, after dinner?"
Skip comparisons with classmates, "after all that tuition", and questions about rank.
How do you go through the test paper with your child?
Researchers John Hattie and Helen Timperley, in their review of feedback in classrooms, found that feedback is one of the most powerful influences on learning, and that it can help or harm depending on its type and how it is given. A marked paper is feedback, but only once someone works out what each lost mark means.
Sit side by side and let your child do the sorting. For each question that lost marks, ask "What happened here?" and put it in one of five boxes:
Didn't know it: the concept or formula was never really learnt.
Wrong method: knew the topic but picked the wrong approach or got stuck halfway.
Slip: a sign, a copying error, units left out, an arithmetic mistake.
Misread: answered a different question from the one asked.
Ran out of time: left blank or rushed at the end.
Here is a made-up example. Aarav, in Class 9, scores 14 out of 25 in a maths unit test on polynomials. Of the 11 marks he lost, 6 came from two questions on the factor theorem he had never practised (didn't know it), 3 from sign errors (slips) and 2 from a question he left blank at the end (ran out of time). Without the sort, the lesson is "maths is hard". With it: "learn the factor theorem, check signs".
For a longer walk-through, see our guide on how to go through a returned test paper with your child. If most of the marks went to slips, read how parents can respond to silly mistakes in maths exams.
What one change should you try before the next test?
Pick the box that cost the most marks and make one change for that box only. One change is doable, and you can tell whether it worked.
Didn't know it: relearn the topic, then explain it out loud to you without looking at notes.
Wrong method: redo the missed questions from a blank page, then three similar ones.
Slip: a two-minute check at the end of each answer, looking only at signs and units.
Misread: underline what the question asks before writing anything.
Ran out of time: one timed practice set a week at home.
Whichever box you choose, practise by recalling, not by rereading. In Roediger and Karpicke's 2006 experiments, students either restudied prose passages or took recall tests on them. On final tests given 2 days or 1 week later, the students who had been tested remembered much more, even though rereading made the other group feel more confident.
If the sort points to a wrong method, the Fermi Problem Library has worked problems with a step-by-step solver that explains the reasoning rather than printing an answer. For a concept gap, every concept in the Fermi Concept Library has its own lesson.
When is a low mark a sign of something bigger?
One low unit test is information, not a crisis. Watch for patterns: marks falling across subjects, reluctance to go to school, or lasting changes in sleep, appetite or mood. Talk to the class teacher first; they see the work every week.
If your child seems persistently anxious or low, speak to a doctor or school counsellor. Tele MANAS, the national mental-health helpline launched by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, is free and open 24x7 on 14416 or 1800-891-4416. If tears are the main problem, read what to say when your child cries over low marks.
Next week, look back together at the box you picked and ask one question: did the change help?
