On this page
It is 9:30 pm, the maths test is tomorrow, and you have explained the same step three times. Your voice goes up before you decide to raise it. If that sounds familiar, you are not a bad parent, and a plan made in advance can stop it.
Why does homework turn into shouting?
Homework puts your worry about marks, your child's tiredness and a problem neither of you can quite do at the same table. Researchers who reviewed parents' involvement in schoolwork concluded that how parents get involved determines in large part whether it helps, not just how much they do.
Shouting also feeds itself. In a study by Ming-Te Wang and Sarah Kenny in Child Development, harsh verbal discipline from mothers and fathers at age 13 predicted an increase in conduct problems and depressive symptoms between ages 13 and 14. The loop ran the other way too: misbehaviour at 13 predicted more harsh words from parents a year later. The study followed nearly 1,000 two-parent families in the United States, so it is not an Indian sample, but the pattern is easy to recognise.
The study measured harsh verbal discipline with questions about shouting, yelling or screaming at the child, swearing, and calling the child names like "dumb" or "lazy", according to the Society for Research in Child Development's summary of the study. The same summary quotes Wang, who led the study: "parents' warmth didn't lessen the effects of harsh verbal discipline." Being loving the rest of the day does not cancel the shouting out.
What should I do the moment I feel like shouting?
Calm responses are hard to invent mid-anger, so decide yours now. A five-step pause plan:
Know your warning signs. Write down your three: a hot face, "How many times have I told you", snatching the pencil. When one appears, the plan starts.
Say your set line. "I'm getting frustrated. I'm taking a short break. This is not your fault." Use the same words every time.
Leave the table. Fill a glass of water, step onto the balcony, breathe slowly.
Name the feeling to yourself. "I'm scared about tomorrow's test" is more useful than "he's not trying". In a brain-imaging study in Psychological Science, putting feelings into words reduced the response of the amygdala, a brain area involved in emotion, to upsetting pictures. That was a lab task, not a homework fight, but it costs nothing to try.
Come back with one question. "Show me the last step that made sense." Then listen to the answer before you explain anything.
How do I repair with my child after shouting?
Do it the same evening if you can, once you are both calm, and keep it short. A four-part script:
Own it: "I shouted at you during maths. That was not okay."
Name it without a "but": "I was worried about the test, and I took it out on you."
Separate them from the mistake: "Getting stuck is normal. You are not lazy."
Say what changes: "Next time I feel it, I'll take my break instead."
Then stop talking. Don't ask for an apology back or reopen the sum. For more on the words to use, read our guide on how to apologise to your child after losing your temper.
How can I stop homework fights before they start?
A research synthesis on parent involvement in homework found that training parents to help with homework led to higher completion rates and fewer homework problems among primary school children, and that parent rule-setting had a stronger link with achievement than other kinds of involvement. Rules agreed in advance do some of the work your voice would otherwise do.
Fix the time and place. Same slot, same table, phone in another room, ideally not the last hour before bed.
Change your job. Sit nearby and be the person who asks "what is the question asking?", not the one who solves it. Our post on helping a Class 8 child with maths without solving it shows how.
Expect pushback on corrections. If your child flares up when you point out errors, try the approach in what to do when your child gets angry when corrected.
Have a fallback for the problem you cannot explain. Many fights start when neither of you knows the method. The Fermi Problem Library has worked problems with a step-by-step solver that explains the reasoning rather than printing an answer, so the next step comes from the page, not from a raised voice.
Both numbers are listed by IIT Kanpur's counselling service, which describes Tele MANAS as a national helpline launched by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.
Tonight, write down your three warning signs and your set line, and stick them where you sit for homework.
