On this page
The results come out. The school posts a banner, or a message on the class WhatsApp group, with the top ten names and photos. Your child, who worked hard and did reasonably well, goes quiet at dinner. The moment is worth taking seriously without making it bigger than it is. Here is what a rank measures, what to say at home, and how to raise it with the school.
Why does a toppers list make my child feel bad?
A toppers list turns marks into a ranking, and a ranking only tells you where you stand compared with the people around you. Research helps explain why that stings.
The big-fish-little-pond effect is the finding that students judge their own ability against their classmates, so the same student feels less capable among stronger peers. In a study of 103,558 fifteen-year-olds across 26 countries, Herbert Marsh and Kit-Tai Hau found that higher school-average achievement went with lower academic self-concept in every one of the 26 countries (American Psychologist, 2003).
Rank can also stick. Richard Murphy and Felix Weinhardt used data on English school students and found that a pupil's rank in their primary-school class had lasting effects on later test scores, confidence and subject choice that were independent of underlying ability (Review of Economic Studies, 2020). Those effects showed up even after the pupils moved to secondary schools where new teachers and classmates did not know their old rank.
That is the idea to share with your child: a rank is a fact about the room, not about your brain.
What should I say when my child is not on the list?
You need a calm conversation, ideally a day after the list, not that evening. Try this order:
Listen first. "You went quiet after the list came out. What was that like?" Do not rush to "marks don't matter"; they matter to your child today.
Name the feeling. "It sounds like you felt invisible, as if your work didn't count."
Separate rank from learning. "The list shows who scored highest this time. It doesn't show what you learned, or how far you've come since the last test."
Find their own evidence. Put this test next to the previous one and go chapter by chapter. Which topic went up? Which mistake has stopped appearing?
Choose one next step together: one chapter or one type of question to work on before the next test.
Two things to avoid: comparing with the topper ("see how hard she studies"), and promising a reward for making the list next time. Both keep the rank at the centre. Our guide to celebrating improvement instead of rank has more ways to notice progress, and if the comparing has spread to friends, see what to do when your child compares marks with friends.
If the next step is a concept that never quite clicked, the Fermi Concept Library has its own lesson for each concept in physics, chemistry, biology and mathematics, so your child can start from the gap rather than from the list.
Should I talk to the school about the toppers list?
Yes, if the list is very public, happens after every test, or your child stays upset for days. Go in as a partner, not a complainant.
It helps to know that you are not asking for anything unusual. CBSE dropped merit lists for its board results: in July 2022 its Examination Controller, Sanyam Bhardwaj, said the board had decided not to declare them, to eliminate "unhealthy competition", and it also stopped awarding first, second and third divisions (The Tribune). The board still gives merit certificates to the top 0.1% of students in each subject, according to the same report.
A five-step plan for the meeting:
Ask for a short meeting with the class teacher rather than raising it in a crowded parent-teacher meeting. Our list of questions to ask at a parent-teacher meeting helps you prepare.
Open with something that is working: a subject your child enjoys, or a teacher they like.
Describe the effect, not the blame: "Since the results board went up, my son has said his work doesn't count."
Make one specific request. For example: recognise most-improved students alongside the toppers, share ranks privately instead of on banners or WhatsApp groups, or add a line in the report on what each child did well.
Ask what the teacher sees: "What is one thing he does well in class that the marks don't show?" Then agree when you will check in again.
A sentence that keeps it friendly: "I'm not asking you to stop celebrating toppers. I'm asking whether the school could also recognise improvement, so children in the middle feel seen."
When is it more than disappointment?
Some disappointment after results is expected. If your child stops wanting to go to school, has trouble sleeping or eating, or talks about feeling worthless, speak to the school counsellor or a doctor. Tele MANAS, the government's 24x7 toll-free mental health helpline, is on 14416 (Press Information Bureau).
Tonight, start small: ask your child what they are proudest of from this term, and listen to the whole answer.
