On this page
Nothing travels faster than light in a vacuum. But light in water moves at only about three quarters of that speed, and a fast enough electron can overtake it. When it does, it gives off a faint blue glow. This post covers how Pavel Cherenkov found that glow, how he proved it was something new, and how to calculate the angle of the light with Class 12 optics.
Who was Pavel Cherenkov?
His Nobel Prize facts page gives his birth as 28 July 1904 in Novaya Chigla, Russia, and his death on 6 January 1990. His Nobel biography says his parents were peasants. He graduated from Voronezh State University in 1928 and in 1930 joined the P. N. Lebedev Physical Institute in Moscow, where in 1934, working under S. I. Vavilov, he observed blue light from a bottle of water under radioactive bombardment.
The 1958 Nobel Prize in Physics went jointly to Cherenkov, Ilya Frank and Igor Tamm "for the discovery and the interpretation of the Cherenkov effect".
How did he prove it was not fluorescence?
Many liquids glow under radiation because of impurities, so the obvious guess was ordinary luminescence. Cherenkov's Nobel lecture explains how he ruled that out.
Measuring with the eye. Photomultipliers did not exist yet. He used a visual method developed by Brumberg and Vavilov that relied on the dark-adapted human eye, which he notes is tens of thousands of times more sensitive than in daylight.
Trying to quench it. Fluorescence can be dimmed by heating the liquid or adding quenchers. Heating, potassium iodide and silver nitrate had no effect on the new light, though they did dim a known fluorescent solution.
Checking polarisation. The light's electric vibrations ran parallel to the gamma-ray beam, not across it as in polarised fluorescence.
Finding the real source. The light came not from the gamma rays directly but from fast electrons they knocked loose (Compton electrons). X-rays of about 30 keV produced nothing.
In 1936 he found the decisive property. The light was emitted only forwards, at a definite angle to the beam.
How did Frank and Tamm explain it?
The facts page says Frank and Tamm explained the effect in 1937. A charged particle disturbs the electrons of the medium as it passes, and they give off light. Normally these small waves cancel. If the particle moves faster than light moves in that medium, the waves pile up along a cone, a kind of optical wake. Cherenkov's lecture compares it to the shock wave from a supersonic aircraft and the bow wave of a boat. Our post on Ernst Mach and shock waves covers the sound version.
The theory gives the angle θ between the light and the particle's path:
cos θ = 1 / (βn), where β = v/c and n is the refractive index.
Since cos θ cannot exceed 1, light appears only when βn > 1, that is, when v > c/n. That is the threshold.
Worked example: Cherenkov light in water
The NCERT Class 12 chapter Ray Optics and Optical Instruments lists the refractive index of water as 1.33 and gives c = 3 × 10⁸ m/s.
Speed of light in water: c/n = 3 × 10⁸ / 1.33 = 2.26 × 10⁸ m/s, about 75% of c.
Threshold: the particle must have β > 1/1.33 = 0.752.
Angle for a very fast particle (β ≈ 1): cos θ = 1/1.33 = 0.752, so θ ≈ 41°.
Angle just above threshold, β = 0.80: cos θ = 1/(0.80 × 1.33) = 0.940, so θ ≈ 20°.
Faster particles give wider cones, up to a maximum of about 41° in water. Detectors use this: the size of the ring of light tells you the speed. For an electron, reaching β = 0.752 needs a kinetic energy of about 0.26 MeV, a figure that uses special relativity and goes beyond the JEE syllabus.
Common mistakes:
Comparing the particle with c instead of c/n. Nothing outruns light in a vacuum.
Measuring θ from the wrong line. It is the angle between the light and the particle's direction of motion.
Getting cos θ > 1. That just means the particle is below threshold and there is no Cherenkov light.
If the link between refractive index and speed still feels like a formula to memorise, the Fermi Concept Library covers every concept in physics, so you can review it before you try these problems. Our post on common ray optics mistakes covers the classroom side.
Where is Cherenkov light used today?
His biography notes that the Cherenkov detector became standard equipment for detecting high-speed particles and measuring their speed, and that one flew on Sputnik III. The largest modern example is Super-Kamiokande in Japan, a tank of 50,000 tonnes of water whose light sensors watch for Cherenkov rings from neutrino collisions. Its results are the subject of our post on Takaaki Kajita and neutrino oscillations.
What can a student take from Cherenkov's way of working?
Eliminate before you claim. Each test removed one ordinary explanation.
Use the instrument you have. A trained, dark-adapted eye did the job of equipment that did not exist yet.
Look for a property that only the new idea predicts. The forward angle was the clue that led to the theory.
Next step: find the threshold β and the maximum angle for glass with n = 1.52, using the same four steps.
