On this page
Many students who struggle with algebra in Class 9 or with calculus in Class 11 trace the trouble back to the same place: they never felt sure about fractions. A 2012 study in Psychological Science tested this with two large national datasets and found that fractions, along with division, stand out among early maths skills. Here is what it did, what it found and what it means for students and parents.
What question did the study ask?
Robert Siegler and seven colleagues published Early Predictors of High School Mathematics Achievement. They asked which kinds of maths knowledge in late primary school most strongly predict algebra and overall maths in high school, once you account for general intelligence, family background and other maths skills.
Who was studied?
According to the full paper (ERIC copy), the study used two long-running samples:
United Kingdom: 3,677 children from the British Cohort Study, all born in one week of 1970, tested at age 10 (1980) and age 16 (1986).
United States: 599 children from a nationally representative US panel, tested at 10 to 12 (1997) and 15 to 17 (2002).
At the younger age, the researchers separated five maths skills: fractions, addition, subtraction, multiplication and division. They controlled for verbal and nonverbal IQ, working memory (US data), family income, parents' education, age and gender.
What did it find?
In the UK data, fractions knowledge at age 10 was the strongest of the five maths predictors of algebra at 16. A one standard deviation difference in early fractions knowledge went with a 0.15 standard deviation difference in algebra, and 0.16 in total maths, after all controls.
The US data showed relations of about the same strength.
Whole-number division was the other standout, second strongest in the UK data and strongest in the US data.
Addition, subtraction and multiplication predicted much less once the other factors were controlled.
Fractions and division did not uniquely predict most later literacy scores, so they were not simply a marker of being generally clever.
In high school, fractions knowledge correlated very strongly with overall maths: 0.81 in the UK and 0.87 in the US.
The paper also gives a telling example. US high school students were asked how long a flight would take for a boy visiting his grandmother 1,400 miles away on a plane travelling at 400 miles per hour. Only 56% answered correctly.
Why might fractions matter so much for algebra?
The paper gives examples. A student who understands fractions can see that in (1/3)x = (2/3)y, x must be twice as large as y, and that in (3/4)x = 6, x must be "somewhat, but not greatly, larger than 6". Let us work these:
(1/3)x = (2/3)y. Multiply both sides by 3: x = 2y. So x is twice y.
(3/4)x = 6. Multiply both sides by 4/3: x = 6 times 4/3 = 8. Since 3/4 is less than 1, x has to be bigger than 6, which is a quick check on the answer.
The flight question: 1,400 divided by 400 = 3.5 hours.
A common mistake in the second one is multiplying 6 by 3/4 to get 4.5. Students who can estimate with fractions notice straight away that the answer must be more than 6.
What does the study not show?
It is correlational. It does not prove that teaching fractions better would raise algebra scores, though it makes that a sensible bet.
The cohorts are old. The UK children were born in 1970; curricula have changed.
It covers the UK and US only. A later study by Torbeyns, Schneider, Xin and Siegler tested 187 sixth and eighth graders in Belgium, China and the US and, according to its accepted manuscript, found consistent strong correlations between fraction number line estimation and maths achievement in all three countries.
What does it mean for students and parents in India?
Fractions are a Class 6 and Class 7 topic in NCERT maths. Our guides to fractions in Class 6 and working with fractions in Class 7 cover the chapters.
Check magnitude, not just procedure. Ask: which is bigger, 5/8 or 3/5? Where does 7/4 sit on a number line? A child who can only follow cross-multiplication rules has a gap.
Estimate before calculating. Before solving (3/4)x = 6, say whether x is more or less than 6.
Treat division as a skill to master, not something the calculator does. Long division and "how many times does 400 go into 1,400" thinking matter.
Older students: if algebra feels shaky, spend a week rebuilding fractions. It is not going backwards.
If a fraction or division idea has gaps, the Fermi Concept Library covers every concept in physics, chemistry, biology, mathematics and computing, so you can revisit the basic idea without hunting through old textbooks.
How to read a study like this
Look for the phrase "after controlling for". A raw correlation between fractions and algebra is not surprising. What makes this study informative is that the link stayed after IQ, family income and other maths skills were taken into account, and that it appeared in two separate countries.
Next step: ask your child (or yourself) to place 3/5, 5/8 and 7/4 on a number line from 0 to 2, and talk through any hesitation.
