On this page
Your child reads a maths problem, stares at it for ten seconds and says, "I can't do this." You explain it all, they copy it, and tomorrow it happens again. Staying with a hard problem is a skill you can teach at home with four habits: a short first try, one hint at a time, words for the stuck feeling, and praise for the method.
Why does my child give up so quickly on hard problems?
Part of the answer is what children think being stuck says about them. In six studies by Claudia Mueller and Carol Dweck, fifth graders praised for being intelligent showed less persistence, less enjoyment and worse performance after a failure than children praised for effort. Children praised for intelligence were also more likely to describe it as a fixed trait. If "smart" means "gets it fast", then being stuck feels like proof that you are not smart, and quitting protects you from that feeling.
Parents send this message without meaning to. Kyla Haimovitz and Dweck found that parents who see failure as debilitating focus on their children's performance and ability rather than on their learning, and their children tend to believe intelligence is fixed. Children could read their parents' views on failure accurately. So the way you react to a wrong answer matters as much as the way you praise a right one.
Is it good to let a child struggle with a problem?
Often, yes, if the struggle is short and supported. Tanmay Sinha and Manu Kapur pooled 53 studies with 166 comparisons and found a moderate advantage (Hedges' g 0.36) for solving a problem first and being taught afterwards, compared with being taught first. One caveat matters for parents: for younger learners, second to fifth graders, the results leaned the other way and favoured teaching first. More on the method is in our post on what the productive failure meta-analysis found.
The two-minute try rule
This is our suggestion, not a number from a study: before anyone helps, your child spends two minutes on the problem alone. The goal is not an answer but something to show you: a sketch, the numbers underlined, a formula that might fit, or where they got stuck. A timer makes the rule feel fair. When it goes off, ask, "Show me what you tried," before you offer any help.
How do I give hints without giving the answer?
Use a hint ladder. Start at the top rung and go down one rung only when the one above has not worked.
Restate: "What is the question actually asking for?"
Recall: "What do you know that connects to this?"
Narrow: "Can you do just the first part?"
Show one step, then hand the pencil back.
Worked example: a train covers 180 km in 3 hours, then 120 km in 1 hour. What is its average speed? Your child says 90 km/h, the average of 60 and 120, and wants to quit when told it is wrong. Rung 1: "What does average speed mean here?" Rung 2: "What two totals do you need?" If they are still stuck, rung 3: "Add up the distance first." They get 300 km, then 4 hours, then 75 km/h. They did the final step themselves. For what tutoring research says about this kind of help, see our post on hints versus answers in tutoring research.
If the topic is one you have forgotten, the Fermi Problem Library has worked problems with a step-by-step solver that explains the reasoning rather than printing an answer, so you can follow the method before you start the ladder.
What should I say when my child says "I can't do this"?
Name the feeling first, then the next step. Putting feelings into words is called affect labelling. In one brain-imaging lab study, labelling a feeling reduced the response of the amygdala to upsetting images. That study was not about children or homework, so it does not prove this helps, but it is gentle and worth trying.
Instead of "It's easy, just think," say: "This one feels stuck. That's the feeling of learning something new."
Instead of "Wow, that was fast," say: "Drawing the diagram first is what cracked it."
Instead of "You're so smart," say: "You tried two methods before this one worked."
Elizabeth Gunderson and colleagues found that parents' praise of effort to children aged 14 to 38 months predicted a belief that ability can grow at age 7 to 8, in a sample of 53 children. Our guide to process praise versus "you're so smart" has more phrases you can use.
When is it more than ordinary frustration?
Speak to your child's teacher or a counsellor if it spreads to every subject, comes with tears or refusing to go to school, or follows a sudden change in sleep or mood. If your child seems persistently low or anxious, Tele MANAS, the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare's free 24x7 mental-health helpline, is on 14416 or 1800-891-4416.
This week, try one problem a day with the timer, the ladder and one sentence of strategy praise.
