On this page
Chemistry on paper is flat. A Lewis structure, a wedge-and-dash drawing and a ball-and-stick picture can all describe the same molecule, and much of the difficulty in VSEPR, isomerism and organic chemistry is moving between them in your head. A 3D viewer lets you hold the molecule, turn it, and check what your drawing actually means.
What does research say 3D models help with?
The skill at stake is translating between representations. Robert Kozma and Joel Russell compared professional chemists with undergraduates and found that experts grouped chemistry representations by concepts, while novices grouped them by surface features1098-2736(199711)34:9%3C949::AID-TEA7%3E3.0.CO;2-U), and experts were better at turning one representation into another.
Two studies looked at tools that build this skill:
Wu, Krajcik and Soloway (2001). In a six-week study with 71 eleventh graders, students used eChem, a tool for building molecular models and seeing several representations at once. Their understanding of chemical representations improved substantially between pre- and post-tests. Students who were highly engaged in discussion while using the tool made more links between the visual and conceptual sides. The authors also noted that students did not use all types of 3D model interchangeably.
Stull, Hegarty, Dixon and Stieff (2012). Across three studies, students translated between organic chemistry diagrams with or without a hand-held model. The model groups outperformed control groups, and students who received and used models outperformed those who received but did not use them. Spatial ability predicted performance much less than model use did, and some students needed direct instruction to benefit.
The lesson from both: a model helps when you act on it, by rotating it, comparing it and explaining it. Having it on the screen is not enough. Both were single studies in particular settings, so treat them as encouraging, not as proof that any tool will work for you.
Which free tools are worth trying?
PhET Molecule Shapes. You build molecules in 3D, add single, double or triple bonds and lone pairs to the central atom, and compare the model to real molecules. It is built for VSEPR.
PubChem. This free chemistry database has a page for each compound, and many compounds, methane included, have a 3D structure you can view.
A physical model kit. Stull's 2012 studies used concrete models. If you have one, it works the same way.
A worked example: why is water bent?
Use these facts from the OpenStax Chemistry textbook: methane is tetrahedral with 109.5° bond angles, the H–N–H angles in ammonia are slightly smaller than 109.5°, and water is bent at 104.5°. The same section explains that a lone pair occupies a larger region of space than a bonding pair, and that electron-pair geometry and molecular structure are identical when there are no lone pairs.
Now test it in Molecule Shapes:
Build a central atom with four single bonds. Predict the angle, then check: tetrahedral, 109.5°.
Replace one bond with a lone pair. Before you look, predict whether the remaining angles get bigger or smaller. You should see the bonds pushed closer together, as in ammonia.
Replace a second bond with a lone pair. Predict again. This is the water case.
Look at the water model twice: once counting the lone pairs, once looking only at the atoms. Counting lone pairs, the four electron pairs still point roughly to the corners of a tetrahedron. Looking only at the atoms, you see a bent molecule. That is the difference between electron-pair geometry and molecular shape.
A 20-minute draw, build, redraw routine
Draw from memory (3 minutes). Lewis structure and a rough 3D sketch.
Predict (2 minutes). Name the shape and estimate the bond angle.
Build and rotate (5 minutes). Use the tool. Turn the molecule until you can see why your sketch was right or wrong.
Close the tool and redraw (5 minutes). Draw the 3D structure again with wedges and dashes, from memory.
Translate (5 minutes). Draw the same molecule from a different viewpoint, or as a different representation. This is the skill Kozma and Russell found separates experts from novices.
The same routine works for isomers and for checking whether two drawings are the same molecule. For more on pairing words with pictures, see our guide to dual coding in your notes, and for organic chemistry, learning mechanisms rather than lists.
Where Fermi fits
The Fermi Simulation Lab has interactive simulations for ideas that are easier to see than to read. If bonding itself is the gap, the Fermi Concept Library has a lesson for each chemistry concept. Pick one molecule you find confusing and run the routine on it tonight.
