On this page
Free graphing apps such as Desmos or GeoGebra will draw any function you type, instantly. That can make calculus click: you see a derivative as a slope and a definite integral as an area. It can also become a way to avoid thinking, because you never have to work out a shape yourself. In a pen-and-paper exam you will not have the plot. This post shows what research says about graphing tools and how to use them so your hand-sketching gets stronger, not weaker.
Do graphing tools help students learn maths?
On average, yes. A meta-analysis by Ellington (2006) combined 42 studies comparing students who had graphing calculators during instruction with students who did not, from middle school to first-semester calculus. Students benefited when calculators were part of instruction, and when calculators were used in both instruction and testing, procedural, conceptual and overall achievement improved.
An older classroom study shows how. In Heid (1988), two college applied-calculus classes used graphing and symbol-manipulation software for routine work for the first 12 weeks and spent only the last 3 weeks on hand skills. They showed better understanding of course concepts and did almost as well on a final exam of routine skills as a class that had practised those skills for all 15 weeks.
The pattern in both is the same. The tool helps when it frees time for thinking about ideas. It does not help if it replaces the thinking.
Why predict before you plot?
Making a prediction before seeing a result is a learning strategy in its own right. In Brod, Hasselhorn and Bunge (2018), people who generated predictions learned more than people who only evaluated outcomes afterwards, and surprise at a wrong prediction was linked to more learning. A graphing tool is a quick way to get that surprise, but only if you commit to a prediction first.
Worked example 1: sketching a cubic
Take f(x) = x³ − 3x.
Roots. x³ − 3x = x(x² − 3) = 0, so x = 0 or x = ±√3, about ±1.73.
Turning points. f′(x) = 3x² − 3 = 0 gives x = ±1.
Values there. f(1) = 1 − 3 = −2 and f(−1) = −1 + 3 = 2.
Which is which. f″(x) = 6x. At x = 1, f″ = 6 > 0, so (1, −2) is a local minimum. At x = −1, f″ = −6 < 0, so (−1, 2) is a local maximum.
Ends. For large positive x the x³ term wins, so f goes to +∞; for large negative x it goes to −∞.
Now sketch it, and only then plot. If your curve and the tool's curve match, you have checked a full chain of reasoning in seconds. Next, plot f′(x) = 3x² − 3 on the same axes and notice that it crosses zero exactly where f turns, and is negative between x = −1 and x = 1, where f is decreasing.
Worked example 2: an area you can see
Find the area under y = x² from x = 0 to x = 2.
∫ from 0 to 2 of x² dx = [x³/3] from 0 to 2 = 8/3 ≈ 2.67.
Most graphing tools will shade and compute the same definite integral. Before you check, estimate: the region sits inside a 2 by 4 rectangle of area 8, and the curve hugs the x-axis for small x, so the answer should be well under half of 8. 2.67 passes that test.
What mistakes do students make with graphing tools?
Trusting the default window. Compare y = eˣ and y = x¹⁰. On a typical window up to x = 20, x¹⁰ looks far bigger: at x = 20, x¹⁰ ≈ 1.0 × 10¹³ while eˣ ≈ 4.9 × 10⁸. But eˣ overtakes x¹⁰ near x ≈ 35.8 and stays ahead for good. A plot shows only what its window shows; algebra tells you what happens beyond it.
Reading values instead of deriving them. A tool may show a minimum "at about 1". In an exam you must show f′(x) = 0 and justify it.
Mixing up f and f′. Plot both in different colours and say in words what each one tells you.
Plotting first, every time. If you never sketch by hand, the skill you need in the exam hall never forms. Our post on the calculus you need for JEE physics shows how much of that sketching carries into physics.
A weekly routine
Three hand sketches a day. Pick functions from your chapter, for example a cubic, a rational function such as y = 1/(x − 2), and a trig function such as y = sin 2x. Find roots, turning points, asymptotes and end behaviour on paper.
Plot to check. Mark each sketch right or wrong, and write one line on any difference.
One "slider" exploration a week. Plot y = a·sin(bx) with sliders for a and b and predict, before each change, what the graph will do.
Explain the surprise. Keep a list of every prediction the tool proved wrong and the reason why. Review it before tests.
When you cannot see why the graph looks the way it does
If the plot keeps surprising you, the gap is usually a concept, such as what a second derivative means or why an asymptote appears. The Fermi Concept Library has every concept in mathematics with its own lesson and its place in the map, so you can fill that one gap and go back to sketching.
Tonight, sketch f(x) = x³ − 3x by hand from its derivative, then plot it and compare.
