On this page
Northern Europe has milder winters than its latitude suggests, and the last ice age ended with sudden lurches rather than a smooth warming. Wallace Broecker linked both to one feature of the ocean: a deep current he drew as a conveyor belt. This post covers who he was, how the conveyor works, a worked example on the heat it carries, and the working habits behind his ideas.
Who was Wallace Broecker?
Nature's obituary by Peter de Menocal says Broecker grew up in Oak Park, Illinois, and left Wheaton College in 1952 for an internship at Columbia University's Lamont Geological Observatory. He stayed for a 67-year career, calling the place his "Garden of Eden", and wrote more than 500 papers and 17 books. His doctoral work pioneered environmental uses of radiocarbon, and he showed that deep water in the Atlantic is only one to two centuries old, so the deep ocean moves faster than many expected.
He won the Crafoord Prize in Geosciences in 2006 "for his innovative and pioneering research on the operation of the global carbon cycle within the ocean – atmosphere – biosphere system, and its interaction with climate". The Oceanography Society's tribute gives his dates as 1931 to 2019.
Where did the conveyor belt picture come from?
Broecker told the story himself in The Great Ocean Conveyor (1991). The diagram first appeared in a November 1987 article in Natural History magazine about a cold spell called the Younger Dryas. He designed it as a cartoon for lay readers and was surprised when it became a logo for global change research. He even listed its faults: real deep water is a sluggish mass filling most of the deep Atlantic, not a neat ribbon, and it mixes with other water around Antarctica.
He was clear about what was new. Deep water formation in the northern Atlantic had been described in the 1930s. His contribution, he wrote, "lies in the idea that changes in the Atlantic's thermohaline circulation were responsible for the abrupt and large climatic changes" of the last glacial period.
How does the conveyor work?
Near Iceland, winter air from the Canadian Arctic cools the surface water until it is dense enough to sink and flow south as North Atlantic Deep Water. NCERT's Class 11 chapter on movements of ocean water states the rule: cold water and salty water are denser, and denser water sinks.
Broecker argued that salt is the key. Water vapour carried by winds from the Atlantic to the Pacific leaves the Atlantic saltier, on average by about 1 gram per litre at the surface. For deep-water temperatures, he wrote, that extra salt raises density as much as cooling by 3 to 4 °C. North Pacific surface water is so fresh that even at freezing point it sinks only a few hundred metres, so no deep water forms there.
Worked example: how much heat does the conveyor release?
Broecker's 1991 figures: a flow of about 20 Sv, and upper-limb water at about 10 °C cooling to about 3 °C as it becomes deep water. Each cubic centimetre therefore gives up about 7 calories (1 cal per gram per °C, and 1 cm³ of seawater is close to 1 g).
Step 1: flow in cm³ per second. 20 Sv = 20 × 10^6 m³/s = 2 × 10^7 m³/s. One cubic metre is 10^6 cm³, so the flow is 2 × 10^13 cm³/s.
Step 2: heat per second. 2 × 10^13 × 7 = 1.4 × 10^14 cal/s.
Step 3: heat per year. One year is about 3.16 × 10^7 s. 1.4 × 10^14 × 3.16 × 10^7 ≈ 4.4 × 10^21 cal per year. Broecker gives 4 × 10^21 calories a year, equal to about 35% of the sunlight received by the Atlantic north of 40 degrees.
Step 4: in watts. 1.4 × 10^14 cal/s × 4.184 J/cal ≈ 5.9 × 10^14 W, or about 0.6 petawatts.
He also compared the flow with rivers: about twenty times the combined flow of all the world's rivers. Our guide to calorimetry and heat transfer covers the Q = mcΔT step.
Why did he worry about it?
Broecker linked a temporary shutdown of the conveyor to the Younger Dryas, a thousand years of very cold conditions. Nature's obituary quotes his warning from 1998 that the climate system is like "an angry beast and we are poking it with sticks". The obituary also notes that his 1975 Science paper, Climatic Change: Are We on the Brink of a Pronounced Global Warming?, was the first scientific use of "global warming".
What mistakes do students make about ocean circulation?
Thinking only wind drives currents. Surface currents are mostly wind-driven; the deep flow depends on density, set by temperature and salt.
Forgetting salt. Cold water alone is not enough; the North Pacific is cold but too fresh.
Taking the cartoon literally. Broecker himself said the logo oversimplifies the paths and the mixing.
What can a student learn from Broecker?
The Oceanography Society's tribute says he was often right but was "the first to admit publicly when he was wrong". He also drew a simple picture to explain a complex idea, then listed its limits. Do both in your own studying: make the diagram, then write what it leaves out. His early evidence for the orbital theory of ice ages links his work to Milutin Milankovic.
If density, salinity and heat capacity feel like disconnected facts, the Fermi Concept Library covers every concept in physics, chemistry, biology, mathematics and computing.
Try it now: redo the worked example for a weaker conveyor of 12 Sv and compare the heat released.
