On this page
In SN1 reactions, Markovnikov additions and rearrangements, your textbook draws a carbocation in the middle of the mechanism. For decades that carbocation was a reasonable guess that nobody had actually seen, because it vanishes almost as soon as it forms. George Olah, a Hungarian-born chemist, found a way to keep carbocations alive long enough to measure them directly. This post covers his journey, the chemistry that made it work, a worked example, common mistakes, and the working habit that stands out in his own account.
Who was George Olah?
His Nobel Prize facts page records that he was born in Budapest on 22 May 1927 and died in Los Angeles on 8 March 2017. He received the 1994 Nobel Prize in Chemistry alone, "for his contribution to carbocation chemistry", while at the University of Southern California.
In his Nobel autobiography he describes studying chemistry at the Technical University of Budapest, where demanding oral exams cut the class roughly in half in the first year. As an assistant he set up a small "balcony laboratory" for fluorine chemistry and the study of Friedel-Crafts reactions and their intermediates, making basic chemicals such as HF himself. After the 1956 Hungarian uprising he left with his family and much of his research group, reaching Canada in 1957. His first work on stable carbocations started in the late 1950s at Dow Chemical's laboratory in Sarnia, Ontario. He later moved to Western Reserve University in Cleveland in 1965 and to USC in 1977.
Why were carbocations so hard to study?
The 1994 press release explains the problem. In the 1920s and 1930s, Ingold, Hughes and Meerwein showed that many organic reactions seem to pass through positively charged carbon species. These intermediates live for roughly 10^-10 to 10^-6 seconds, so they exist at concentrations far too low to observe with spectroscopy. Most chemists assumed they would never be prepared in useful amounts.
How did Olah keep carbocations alive?
The press release lists three ingredients:
Superacids. These are acids stronger than 100% sulphuric acid. Mixtures such as HF with antimony pentafluoride (SbF5), or HSO3F with SbF5 (sold as Magic Acid), are described as about 10^18 times stronger than 100% sulphuric acid.
Very weakly nucleophilic solvents, such as SO2, SO2ClF and SO2F2, which do not attack the carbocation.
Low temperatures, usually between −78 °C and −120 °C.
Under these conditions alkyl halides and alcohols give carbocations at high concentration, and their structures can be read from 1H and 13C NMR spectra. The press release adds that Olah's group observed the much-debated 2-norbornyl cation at −158 °C, and that superacids can even protonate alkanes such as methane, giving five-coordinate carbon.
Worked example: following a carbocation step by step
The press release uses isopropyl chloride, (CH3)2CHCl, as its example. Let us trace it.
Ionisation. The C–Cl bond breaks heterolytically. Chlorine leaves with both bonding electrons as Cl−, leaving (CH3)2CH+, a secondary carbocation.
Count the electrons on the central carbon. It now has three bonds, so 3 × 2 = 6 electrons around it, not 8. That empty orbital is why it is so hungry for an electron pair.
Shape. With three groups and no lone pair, the carbon is sp2 hybridised and planar, with bond angles of about 120°.
Fate in a normal reaction. The press release explains that it then either combines with a nucleophile (substitution) or loses a proton to form propene (elimination).
Fate in superacid. With no nucleophile available and the solution cold, it simply stays as the cation, so its NMR spectrum can be recorded.
The press release gives one more striking reaction. In superacid, isobutane, (CH3)3CH, takes on an extra proton and then loses H2, giving the tert-butyl cation, (CH3)3C+. Check the balance: (CH3)3CH + H+ → (CH3)3C+ + H2. Carbon 4 = 4, hydrogen 10 + 1 = 9 + 2, charge +1 = +1.
The NCERT Class 12 unit on haloalkanes uses the same logic for SN1 reactions: the more stable the carbocation, the faster the alkyl halide reacts, which is why tertiary halides react fastest.
What mistakes do students make with carbocations?
Giving the positive carbon eight electrons. It has six. Count bonds, not atoms.
Drawing it tetrahedral. A simple carbocation is planar, which is why SN1 can give attack from either face.
Forgetting rearrangements. A secondary cation next to a more substituted carbon can shift a hydride or methyl to become tertiary.
Confusing carbocations with free radicals. A radical is neutral with seven electrons around carbon.
For the full stability order and practice ranking problems, read our post on reaction intermediates. If a mechanism step still does not make sense, the Fermi Problem Library has a step-by-step solver that explains the reasoning rather than printing an answer.
What can a student learn from how Olah worked?
Olah's carbocation work was rooted in Friedel-Crafts chemistry, the reaction described in our post on Friedel and Crafts. He chose to chase the intermediate everyone assumed was unobservable, and he worked in a converted balcony with home-made reagents rather than wait for a better lab. In his autobiography he also notes that he kept researching after the Nobel Prize, determined that it would not change his habits. Pick one mechanism you only half believe, and ask what evidence would show the intermediate really exists.
Draw the carbocation formed from 2-methyl-2-butanol in acid, count the electrons on the positive carbon, and predict the alkene it gives on losing a proton.
